# Publish-gate review record (docs/PUBLISH_GATE.md). status: pending | passed | passed_with_open_items | grandfathered | failed
subject: casket-letters
status: grandfathered
checks:
- check: 'conformance: no errors for this subject'
  result: FAIL
  detail: 'ERROR    publish-gate:casket-letters: published subject has no review.yaml (docs/PUBLISH_GATE.md)'
- check: headline present, 70-95 characters
  result: pass
  detail: 94 characters
- check: headline claim is established/refuted at high confidence with a primary check, or status is draft
  result: pass
  detail: 'casket-originals-lost: established, provisional, anchor_checked secondary; headline_status draft'
- check: headline_status is draft or review before the gate passes
  result: pass
  detail: draft
- check: assessment present with question, answer, headline, text, basis, would_settle
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: assessment has exactly three key_points
  result: pass
  detail: '3'
- check: assessment states no percentage
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: taxonomy entry (area and question types)
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: every claim has statement_kind
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: every searched gap names its next step
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: sources manifest exists
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: every source has an authenticity block
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: log has entries
  result: pass
  detail: ''
- check: timeline present (dates exist, so a timeline is required)
  result: pass
  detail: ''
open_items:
- 'conformance: no errors for this subject: ERROR    publish-gate:casket-letters: published subject has no review.yaml (docs/PUBLISH_GATE.md)'
- Established claims anchored below primary are shown on the page as limits (anchor_checked).
needs_manual_check:
- '4 established/refuted claims anchored below primary: casket-originals-lost, casket-babington-postscript-forged-1586, casket-four-french-copies-survive,
  casket-too-short-for-wordfreq'
- 'dates, names, patent or document numbers: verify each against the source'
- every refuted claim names its target and rests on material or primary-text evidence (Rule 9)
- no claim goes beyond what was read; anything not read is marked not read
conformance_warnings: 4
established_or_refuted_without_primary_check:
- casket-originals-lost
- casket-babington-postscript-forged-1586
- casket-four-french-copies-survive
- casket-too-short-for-wordfreq
quotes:
  found_in_stored_sources: 0
  not_found_in_stored_sources: 0
  no_stored_source_to_check_against: 0
reviewed_by: Claude (build session), partial review; no independent reviewer
reviewed_on: '2026-10-02'
notes: 'Published by the owner before the gate existed. Read directly: Henderson (1889) in OCR text. The 1586 forgery, the
  French copies'' holdings and the contested-authenticity positions rest on Henderson or on the Q-001 page and were not each
  re-read; the NSA account was not read (nsa.gov blocks this environment). Computed results were reproduced from the published
  code. Headline status is draft.'